Skip to content

Research Library · Study page

Does Orton-Gillingham help struggling readers? A 2021 review of 24 studies

A plain look at a 2021 review of 24 Orton-Gillingham studies. It found a small gain that could be chance. Most of the studies were weak.

Study Facts

Stevens and others, 2021

Review of 24 OG studies

Question
Does OG help struggling readers?

What it found

A little ahead, but it could be chance.

EvidenceLimited

Few studies, mostly small and weak.

Kids
Struggling readers
Ages
Kindergarten to grade 12
Size
24 studies
Fair tests
9 of 24 put kids into groups at random
Measured
Reading tests
By
6 researchers, 3 universities
Paid by
Two U.S. government grants
Conflicts
Not stated

Elizabeth A. Stevens, Christy Austin, Clint Moore, Nancy Scammacca, Alexis N. Boucher and Sharon Vaughn (2021). “Current State of the Evidence: Examining the Effects of Orton-Gillingham Reading Interventions for Students With or at Risk for Word-Level Reading Disabilities.” Exceptional Children, 87(4), 397–417. Read the free full text · Publisher's version
Free author manuscript at PubMed Central. This is the copy we read.

Last reviewed November 16, 2026 · Used in: Does Orton-Gillingham work? What the research says

Go deeper

The study in eight short parts. Tap a part to open it.

1

What is the study?

A 2021 review that pooled the results of many OG studies.

Orton-Gillingham, or OG, is a way to teach reading in small steps. It is aimed at kids with dyslexia.

A review gathers many studies and puts their results together. This one found 24 studies of OG, up to March 2019. It pooled 16 of them. It updates a 2006 review of 12 studies.

2

Why this matters to you

OG is widely used for kids with dyslexia, and some states require it. This review asked if it works.

Several states require OG training or OG programs by law. If a school or tutor offers you OG, this review tells you what is known about it.

3

What was measured?

Reading skills. Did kids who got OG read better than kids who did not?

What the review measured

Basic reading skills

  • Hearing the sounds in words
  • Phonics
  • Smooth reading
  • Spelling

Understanding

  • Word meanings
  • Understanding what they read

Source: Stevens and others, 2021.

Each study had to measure at least one reading skill, such as word reading, spelling or understanding.

4

Who was measured?

Struggling readers from kindergarten to grade 12.

Who was in the studies
  • 24studies found
  • K to 12kindergarten to grade 12
  • 10 to 407students in each study
  • Dyslexiaor at risk for it, or struggling to read

Source: Stevens and others, 2021, Table 2.

The review left out college students. It also left out OG taught to a whole class.

5

How was it measured?

Each study compared kids who got OG with kids who did not. Then the researchers pooled the results.

From hundreds of papers to one answer
  1. 354summaries of papers checked
  2. 109papers read in full
  3. 24studies kept
  4. 16studies pooled for the main result

Source: Stevens and others, 2021, Method and Results.

To be kept, a study had to test OG one to one or in small groups. It had to compare an OG group with another group. It had to be printed in English, in a journal that reviews its papers or as a dissertation.

Why were only 16 of the 24 pooled? Five had fewer than 10 students in each group. Three did not report enough numbers.

How strong were the 24 studies?

Each square is one study.

  • 9 of 24 studies put kids into groups at random, the fairest kind of test

  • 4 of 24 studies kept a useful record that lessons were taught as planned

Source: Stevens and others, 2021, Study Quality and Table 3.

6

The results

OG kids were a little ahead. But the gap could be chance.

Did kids taught with OG do better?
  • Basic reading skills: hearing sounds in words, phonics, smooth reading and spelling

    A little ahead, but it could be chanceHow sure: Limited

    15 studies

  • Word meanings and understanding what they read

    A little ahead, but it could be chanceHow sure: Limited

    10 studies

Source: Stevens and others, 2021.

The studies were weak, and their results differed a lot. In the authors' words, the results show "promise but not confidence".

Their results do not prove that OG fails, they write. They do not claim that other programs work better, either.

The authors list what to be careful about:

  • Few studies. They expected to find more than 24.
  • Small groups. That made the likely range for the true result very wide.
  • Missing details. Many studies did not say what the other group was taught. So no one can tell how much phonics those kids got.
  • Untested questions. There were too few studies to see if grade level or hours of teaching changed the results.
7

Why this matters to you, again

The OG label is not proof. Look for what is taught, not the brand name.

  • At home. An OG program is a fair choice. But a child with dyslexia does not have to have OG. The authors say the evidence does not show it is "the only approach".
  • The hands-on part. Research does not show that using the senses at once helps kids read, the authors write.
  • In class. The authors point to a lot of evidence for teaching phonics and spelling together.
  • In the law. Several states require OG. The authors say their results "raise concerns" about those laws.
8

Who did the study, and who paid

Who did it. Six researchers: Elizabeth A. Stevens, Christy Austin, Clint Moore, Nancy Scammacca, Alexis N. Boucher and Sharon Vaughn. They worked at Georgia State University, the University of Texas at Austin and the University of Utah.

Who paid. Two U.S. government grants paid for part of the work. One was from the National Institutes of Health. One was from the U.S. Department of Education.

Conflicts of interest. The copy we read does not say if the authors had any conflicts of interest.

Later work. Two of the authors, Christy Austin and Elizabeth Stevens, later wrote a 2023 article with two others. It looks at which parts of OG other research backs.