Research Library · Study page
Do "advanced" phonemic awareness drills help reading? A 2021 expert review
Nine reading researchers looked for evidence that hard sound drills, done by ear past first grade, help kids read. They found none.
Study Facts
Clemens and others, 2021
Expert review
- Question
- Is there evidence for "advanced" sound drills done by ear?
What it found
No evidence that the drills help reading. Teaching sounds with letters works better.
EvidenceExpert view
Nine researchers' reading of other studies. Not peer reviewed when posted.
- What it is
- A summary of other research
- Looked at
- Each claim made for the drills
- By
- 9 researchers
- Paid by
- Not stated
- Conflicts
- None known, the authors say
Nathan H. Clemens, Emily J. Solari, Devin M. Kearns, Hank Fien, Nancy J. Nelson, Melissa V. Stalega, Matthew Burns, Kimberly St. Martin and Fumiko Hoeft (2021). “They Say You Can Do Phonemic Awareness Instruction "In the Dark", But Should You? A Critical Evaluation of the Trend Toward Advanced Phonemic Awareness Training.” PsyArXiv preprint (not peer reviewed in this version). Read the free full text · Publisher's version
Free preprint. We read the version updated December 21, 2021.
Last reviewed November 17, 2026 · Used in: Does phonemic awareness training help?
Go deeper
The study in eight short parts. Tap a part to open it.
1What is the study?
A paper by nine reading researchers. It is not a new experiment. They read the studies others had done. Then they asked if those studies back a trend in U.S. schools: "advanced" phonemic awareness drills.
It was posted in 2021 as a preprint. That means it had not been through peer review yet. The copy we read says it "is currently undergoing peer review".
What are "advanced" drills? Tasks such as saying a word without one of its sounds: "say cat without /k/". Or swapping one sound for another: "change the /k/ to /p/". They are often done by ear, with no letters, and kept up past first grade.
2Why this matters to you
The authors put these drills at 10 to 15 minutes a day. They add that up to 36 to 54 hours a year.
That time could go to reading and spelling instead, they say. Their worry is "what is not happening" while the drills take place.
3What was measured?
No children were tested. The authors checked six claims made for the drills:
- That "advanced" skills are a skill of their own.
- That they tell good readers from poor ones better than other sound tasks.
- That kids need them to read well.
- That they cause better reading, and do not just come from it.
- That teaching them helps reading.
- That theories of how kids learn to read support them.
4Who was measured?
No one, directly. The paper draws on earlier studies of children, teens and adults.
5How was it measured?
The authors read the research behind each claim. They also looked closely at 11 studies that two authors who back the drills had called "highly-effective". On those 11 they found:
- Six had only one group, with nothing to compare against.
- One was not a teaching study.
- Only four were real experiments. None of the 11 let anyone say the advanced drills caused the gains.
6The results
"Advanced" tasks are not a skill of their own. Studies find that tasks with single sounds, easy or hard, seem to measure one skill.
Poor readers are weaker at every sound task, not just the hard ones.
Many good readers do poorly on hard sound tasks. In one study, a third of the kids with above-average decoding scored very low on taking a sound away.
Skill at hard sound tasks partly comes from reading. Learning to read and spell builds it.
No evidence that the drills help reading. The authors knew of one fair test of a program called Heggerty. It was not yet published. As they tell it, kids taught with Heggerty did better on sound tasks. They did no better at sounding out made-up words or at smooth reading. We have not read that study itself.
Sounds with letters work better. Reading results are stronger when phonemic awareness is taught with letters, the authors write.
The authors are fair to the other side:
- They "strongly support" the finding that young kids gain from phonemic awareness teaching.
- Before kids know letters, practice by ear may help.
- Heggerty lessons are clear, and are said to keep kids interested. Heggerty and David Kilpatrick, another backer of the drills, both strongly recommend teaching phonics.
- In themselves, the drills are "probably not" harmful. The worry is the lost time.
- No evidence is not proof that the drills fail.
7Why this matters to you, again
- Blending and breaking apart short words is a strong enough base for reading and spelling, the authors write, citing another researcher.
- Use letters once kids know some.
- Ask about the time. If a school does daily drills by ear past first grade, ask what reading and spelling time they replace.
- Be careful if the drills come first. The authors warn against drills "instead of, or as a prerequisite for" phonics and reading practice.
The paper's own limits:
- It is an argument from other studies, not a new test.
- It rests on a lack of evidence, plus one unpublished trial.
- It was not peer reviewed in the version we read.
- The authors name ways the drills might help, such as memory for sounds. They call for new trials to test them.
8Who did the study, and who paid
Who did it. Nine reading researchers. Eight worked at universities, such as the University of Texas and the University of Virginia. One worked for the state of Michigan's school agency. All nine are named at the top of this page.
Who paid. Not stated.
Conflicts of interest. "The authors have no known conflicts of interest."
Peer review. A preprint: "not the final copy of record", the paper says.
