Skip to content

Research Library · Study page

How can reading trouble be found early? A 2018 review

Three researchers sum up what is known about finding reading trouble early. No single sign reliably predicts it. Signs are warnings to watch.

Study Facts

Colenbrander and others, 2018

Expert review

Question
How can reading trouble be found early?

What it found

No single sign reliably predicts reading trouble. Signs are warnings to monitor a child.

EvidenceExpert view

Three researchers' summary. Not a full search of the research.

What it is
A summary of other research
Looked at
Risk factors, and ways to find children early
By
3 researchers, UK universities
Paid by
Not stated
Conflicts
Not stated

Danielle Colenbrander, Jessie Ricketts and Helen L. Breadmore (2018). “Early Identification of Dyslexia: Understanding the Issues.” Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools, 49, 817–828. Read the free full text · Publisher's version
Free accepted manuscript from the University of Bristol. This is the copy we read. The printed version may differ by a word here and there.

Last reviewed November 17, 2026 · Used in: What are the early signs of dyslexia?

Go deeper

The study in eight short parts. Tap a part to open it.

1

What is the study?

A review by three researchers in the UK. They call it a "tutorial". It sums up research on finding reading trouble early, for speech and language specialists. It is not a full search of every study.

It covers trouble with reading words in general. That includes dyslexia. It also includes reading trouble that does not meet the medical definition.

2

Why this matters to you

Some kinds of help may work best early in school, the authors write. But early checks can also be wrong. This paper explains both sides.

3

What was measured?

No children were tested. The authors summed up research on:

  • the risk factors for trouble reading words,
  • ways to find children at risk,
  • and the mistakes early checks can make.
4

Who was measured?

No one, directly. The paper measured no children of its own. It looks at research on children in preschool and the first two years of school.

5

How was it measured?

  • A summary for people who work with children, not a full search.
  • No pooled numbers of its own.
6

The results

No single sign. "There is no single risk factor which is reliably associated" with later reading trouble, the authors write. The more signs there are, and the stronger they are, the more likely trouble becomes.

Signs are warnings. Signs should be seen as "warning signs", the authors write: a reason to watch a child's early reading closely.

Family history. Children with a family member who has reading trouble are more likely to have it too, the authors write. They suggest watching reading closely in these families.

Sounds and letters. In many studies, hearing the sounds in words is the strongest single predictor of trouble reading words. Letter knowledge is another strong one. But prediction is better when other signs are counted too.

Spoken language. Weak spoken language at the time of learning to read goes with a high risk of later trouble. Children at family risk whose spoken language is on track for their age are less likely to have reading trouble. But a child's vocabulary alone, in preschool or the first school year, is not a reliable sign.

Hearing. Hearing loss of any degree, lasting or passing, is a risk factor, the authors write. That includes repeated ear infections, known as glue ear.

Naming things fast is a strong predictor of later reading. But training broad skills like this has not improved reading, the authors note.

Two kinds of mistake. A wrong alarm can bring needless worry and stress, a label, and wasted time and money. A miss has "serious and long-term" effects, the authors write.

No bright line. Reading skill falls along a range. No cut-off splits all good readers from all poor ones.

Early finding is not enough. Reading trouble can last, or show up later. So progress should be watched over time, the authors write. Early gains may fade.

7

Why this matters to you, again

  • Watch, and ask. A sign is a reason to watch closely, not proof.
  • Help need not wait for a label. In the authors' view, any child whose word reading is not where it should be for their age should get the right help.
  • Speech and language specialists can tell parents that a child may be at risk, the authors write. They can help parents ask the school for assessment and help.

This page is not medical advice.

The paper's own limits:

  • Not a full review. That was "beyond the scope" of the paper.
  • Broad. It is about trouble reading words in general, not only diagnosed dyslexia.
  • Open questions. On the best way for schools to do it, "the jury is still out".
  • Where. It is written with UK and U.S. schools in mind.
8

Who did the study, and who paid

Who did it. Three researchers, at the universities of Bristol, Royal Holloway (London) and Coventry, in the UK.

Who paid. Not stated in the copy we read.

Conflicts of interest. Not stated in the copy we read.