Research Library · Study page
Is the proof for phonics weaker than it looks? A 2021 reply says no
Three researchers wrote back to a 2020 paper on phonics. They see "consistent evidence" for phonics taught clearly. But phonics alone is not best, they agree.
Study Facts
Fletcher and others, 2021
Reply to the 2020 critique
- Question
- Does the 2020 critique read the studies correctly?
What it found
"Consistent evidence" for teaching phonics clearly and on purpose. But phonics alone is not best.
EvidenceExpert view
Three researchers' reading of the same reviews. One side of a debate.
- What it is
- A point-by-point reply
- Looked at
- Each claim in the critique
- By
- 3 researchers, 3 universities
- Paid by
- A U.S. government health institute supported two of the authors
- Conflicts
- None, the authors say
Jack M. Fletcher, Robert Savage and Sharon Vaughn (2021). “A Commentary on Bowers (2020) and the Role of Phonics Instruction in Reading.” Educational Psychology Review, 33(3), 1249–1274 (online November 5, 2020). Read the free full text · Publisher's version
Free author copy on PubMed Central. This is the copy we read. Its tables are pictures, and we did not use them.
Last reviewed November 17, 2026 · Used in: Phonics or whole language: which works better?
Go deeper
The study in eight short parts. Tap a part to open it.
1What is the study?
A reply by three researchers to a 2020 paper by Jeffrey Bowers. He had found "little or no evidence" that phonics in a planned order beats the usual methods. You can read our page on his paper. This reply answers him point by point.
It is one side of a debate. It is not a new study of children.
2Why this matters to you
The two papers look at the same evidence and reach different views. Where they agree tells you as much as where they disagree.
3What was measured?
No children were tested. The authors went through each claim in the critique: what the reviews compared, how large the gains were, and who they helped.
4Who was measured?
No one, directly. The paper measured no children of its own. It reads the reviews Bowers read. It works through one trial of 279 children in detail, as an example.
5How was it measured?
- Point by point. They took the critique's claims in turn.
- A worked example. They looked closely at one trial (Morris and others, 2012).
- No new pooled numbers. It is a commentary, not a new review.
6The results
Where they agree with Bowers. This part is easy to miss:
- The panel's summary "does, as Bowers observes, exaggerate" the more careful findings of its own phonics chapter.
- No one phonics order, and no one way of teaching phonics, is strongly backed. But they think phonics works best with a planned lesson that is "intentional and not incidental".
- There is "very modest evidence" for one kind of phonics, called synthetic phonics, over other methods.
- Studies with poor results may be missing from print, they agree.
- They "fully agree" that there is no evidence that phonics alone is best.
- They expect to share his stand against "overly strong uses of evidence" by some backers of phonics and some policy makers.
Where they disagree.
- In their view, the gains from phonics are not "modest and unimportant".
- They reject calling it "a draw". In their view, that amounts to saying nothing was found. It is "not helpful to educators or their students", they write.
- Against whole language classes, "the positive effect is still evident", they write.
- For older low achievers, they say a gain above zero "was still evident". The panel itself found that gain could be chance.
- Telling teachers to discount the gains is "potentially harmful" to many children who struggle, they write.
Some phonics or planned phonics? Bowers said the reviews mixed classes with some phonics and classes with none. The reply points to a 2008 re-analysis (Stuebing and others). As the reply tells it, that study saw the results as a "dosage effect": more phonics, more gain. We have not read it.
Clear teaching may matter most. Quoting the 2008 paper, they write that being explicit "may be more important" than scripted lessons. Teachers "need to be intentionally clear" about how letters link to the sounds of speech.
Their own worked example. In the 279-child trial, the group taught only phonics did gain. But the authors write that the result "would not meet conventional standards" for being more than chance. In plain words: it could be chance. The trial was too small to detect gains of that size, they add.
Does it last? Gains are "reliably still present" up to about a year after the teaching ends, they write. Past that, the evidence is "limited", they grant.
Understanding text. There is evidence that teaching which includes clear phonics helps smooth reading and understanding, even for kids who struggle most, they write. But the gains in understanding are "more inconsistent".
Guessing. Whole language and balanced literacy "mean different things to different people", they write. The problem, in their view, is too much teaching kids "to guess". Kids should use letter sounds to read the word instead.
England. They do not answer the part of the critique on England. "We do not address findings arising from US or UK government policy", they write.
7Why this matters to you, again
- Both sides agree on a lot. Phonics alone is not best. The panel's summary overstated its own chapter. No one order of teaching is proven best.
- They differ on the gain. The reply sees "consistent evidence" for teaching phonics clearly and on purpose, as part of a wider approach to reading.
- Reading is learned. For most students, reading "requires carefully organized instruction", they write.
The paper's own limits:
- It is a commentary, not a new pooled review.
- Its own worked example found gains that could be chance.
- It does not cover England's national results.
- It grants "some significant weaknesses in the empirical data". Studies with poor results may be missing.
- Evidence past one year is "limited".
- Claims about phonics need words like "may" and "probably", they write.
8Who did the study, and who paid
Who did it. Three researchers. Jack M. Fletcher is at the University of Houston. Robert Savage is at University College London. Sharon Vaughn is at the University of Texas at Austin.
Who paid. A grant from a U.S. government health research institute supported two of the authors, Fletcher and Vaughn.
Conflicts of interest. "None", the authors say.
Numbers that disagree. The paper gives two different counts of the reviews it covers. So we print no count from it.
