Skip to content

Research Library · Study page

What should young kids learn about sounds and letters? A 2016 government guide

A plain look at a 2016 U.S. government teaching guide. Its advice on sounds and letters rests on 17 studies. All 17 found gains in those skills.

Study Facts

Foorman and others, 2016

Government guide, 17 studies

Question
Should young kids be taught to hear sounds and link them to letters?

What it found

All 17 studies found a gain in sound skills, in letter knowledge, or in both.

EvidenceStrong

Every study found a gain, and most were fair tests. But the gains counted were in sound and letter skills, not reading.

Kids
Readers at all levels, and some at risk
Ages
Kindergarten and grade 1
Size
17 studies
Fair tests
12 of 17 met the top standard for a fair test
Measured
Sound skills and letter knowledge
By
A panel of 8 experts
Paid by
The U.S. Department of Education
Conflicts
Disclosed: some panel members earn royalties from reading programs

Barbara Foorman, Nicholas Beyler, Kelley Borradaile, Michael Coyne, Carolyn A. Denton, Joseph Dimino, Joshua Furgeson, Lynda Hayes, Juliette Henke, Laura Justice, Betsy Keating, Warnick Lewis, Samina Sattar, Andrei Streke, Richard Wagner and Sarah Wissel (2016). “Foundational Skills to Support Reading for Understanding in Kindergarten Through 3rd Grade (NCEE 2016-4008).” What Works Clearinghouse practice guide, Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education. Read the free full text · Publisher's version
Free U.S. government report, in the public domain. We read its advice on sounds and letters (Recommendation 2) and the evidence behind it.

Last reviewed November 17, 2026 · Used in: Does phonemic awareness training help?

Go deeper

The study in eight short parts. Tap a part to open it.

1

What is the study?

It is not one study. It is a guide for teachers from the What Works Clearinghouse, part of the U.S. Department of Education. A panel of eight experts wrote it in 2016.

The guide gives four pieces of advice for teaching reading from kindergarten to grade 3. This page is about one of them, advice 2: help kids hear the sounds in words and link them to letters.

Each piece of advice rests on a set of studies. For advice 2 there were 17. The guide only took studies printed from 2000 to 2014. For older work, it points to the National Reading Panel.

2

Why this matters to you

Advice 2 is what many early reading lessons try to do. If your child is in kindergarten or grade 1, the guide says to start this teaching "as soon as possible".

The guide also backs the National Reading Panel. Newer studies support the panel, it says. Kids need to hear the sounds in words and link them to letters.

3

What was measured?

Two things: sound skills and letter knowledge. Could kids hear the sounds in words better? Did they know letter names and sounds better?

For this advice, the guide did not count reading itself. Reading is covered by other parts of the guide, which we did not use here.

  • Eleven studies used standard tests.
  • Three used tests the researchers made.
  • Three used both.
4

Who was measured?

Kids in kindergarten and grade 1:

  • Eleven studies took in kindergartners.
  • Five took in first graders.
  • One took in grades 1 to 4.

Six studies were of kids at risk for reading trouble. Eleven took in readers at all levels. In no study were most kids English learners or kids with a disability. All the studies took place at schools.

5

How was it measured?

Each study compared kids who got the teaching with kids who did not. Most often the other group had its usual class lessons. In a few studies, the other group did math or drawing.

To count, a study had to meet the government's standards for a fair test:

  • Twelve put kids into groups at random and met the top standard.
  • Three more put kids into groups at random and met the standard "with reservations".
  • Two did not use random groups. They also met it with reservations.

Most teaching was in small groups of two to eight kids, on top of usual lessons. Sessions usually lasted 20 to 35 minutes. Most programs ran at least 20 sessions.

6

The results

All 17 found a gain. Each study found a gain in sound skills, letter knowledge or both. Twelve found a gain in sound skills. Nine found a gain in letter knowledge.

The panel rated the evidence "strong". In this guide, strong means several well-designed studies, "leaving little or no doubt" that the teaching caused the gains.

What it does not show. These 17 studies were scored on sound and letter skills, not reading. Also, most of them taught small groups. The advice for whole classes and one-to-one rests on the panel's belief.

The guide turns advice 2 into three steps:

  1. Hear the sounds. Start with words, then syllables, then single sounds.
  2. Learn letter sounds, a few at a time.
  3. Join the two with word-building, such as letter tiles.
7

Why this matters to you, again

  • Start with short words, like dig, sun and at.
  • Use sound boxes. Draw one box for each sound. The child says the word slowly and pulls a disc or a letter tile into a box for each sound. Then the child blends the sounds and says the word.
  • Build words with letter tiles. Make fat. Change one letter to make fan, then can, then cat, then fat again.
  • Sounds you can stretch, like f, m and s, are easier at first.
  • If a child keeps struggling, one-to-one or small-group help often works, the panel says. This is its advice, not a tested result.

The guide names its own limits:

  • It shows "the judgments of the review panel", based on the research of its time.
  • English learners and kids with disabilities were under half of every sample. The panel thinks the advice fits them too. It knows of no evidence against that.
  • No study tested the four pieces of advice together.
8

Who did the study, and who paid

Who did it. A panel of eight experts, led by Barbara Foorman. Staff from a research company, Mathematica Policy Research, helped. Every author is named at the top of this page.

Who paid. The U.S. Department of Education. The guide was made under a contract with Mathematica Policy Research.

Conflicts of interest. The guide lists them. Some panel members earn royalties from reading programs or tests. Two examples:

  • Barbara Foorman earns royalties from a phonemic awareness program. The guide does not mention studies of it.
  • Michael Coyne earns royalties from a kindergarten program. Studies of it are in the guide.

Before it came out, the guide went through an outside peer review.