Skip to content

Research Library · Study page

Which treatments help children with reading disabilities? A 2014 review of 22 trials

A review of 22 fair trials. Only phonics had a confirmed gain, but it had far more trials. For colored overlays or lenses, the gain could be chance.

Study Facts

Galuschka and others, 2014

Pooled review of 22 trials

Question
Which treatments help children with reading disabilities?

What it found

Only phonics had a confirmed gain. For colored overlays and lenses, the gain could be chance.

EvidenceModerate

Only randomized trials. But just 4 comparisons tested colored filters.

Kids
Children and teens with reading disabilities
Ages
Children and teens
Size
22 trials, 49 comparisons
Fair tests
All trials formed groups at random
Measured
Reading and spelling
By
4 researchers, 2 German universities
Paid by
A German dyslexia group and a child psychiatry society
Conflicts
None, the authors say

Katharina Galuschka, Elena Ise, Kathrin Krick and Gerd Schulte-Körne (2014). “Effectiveness of Treatment Approaches for Children and Adolescents with Reading Disabilities: A Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials.” PLoS ONE, 9(2), e89900. Read the free full text · Publisher's version
Free to read on the publisher's site. This is the copy we read.

Last reviewed November 17, 2026 · Used in: Do colored overlays help with dyslexia?

Go deeper

The study in eight short parts. Tap a part to open it.

1

What is the study?

Four researchers in Germany wrote this review. It pooled 22 fair trials of help for children and teens with reading disabilities. The trials held 49 comparisons in all.

It asked which kinds of help improve reading and spelling. It looked at phonics and sound drills. It looked at smooth reading, reading for meaning, listening, and a medicine. And it looked at colored overlays or lenses.

2

Why this matters to you

It is the only review we read that sets colored overlays side by side with other kinds of help, in fair tests. It also says which help was confirmed.

3

What was measured?

Reading and spelling, on tests that were not tied to the lessons.

4

Who was measured?

  • Children and teens with a reading disability. They read well below the level expected. Their IQ was in the normal range.
  • About 1,900 children in all: 1,138 in the groups that got help, and 764 in the groups they were compared with.
  • No adults. No studies of adults could be used.
5

How was it measured?

  • Only randomized trials. Children were put into groups at random. That is the fairest kind of test.
  • Pooled results. The authors put the results together for each kind of help.
  • Blind testing mostly not reported. Sixteen of the 22 trials did not say if the testers knew which group a child was in. So most studies are at risk of bias, the authors conclude.
  • Missing studies. The authors found signs that studies with weak results go unprinted.
6

The results

Only phonics had a confirmed gain. Phonics, here, means teaching letter sounds and how to sound out words, step by step. It was the only kind of help whose gain on reading and spelling was confirmed.

  • The gain was small.
  • After a correction for unprinted studies, it was smaller still, but still beyond chance.

But phonics had far more trials. Phonics had 29 comparisons. Colored overlays or lenses had 4. Their pooled gains were almost the same size. The kinds of help did not differ reliably from each other, the authors found. So this review does not show that phonics beat overlays.

Colored overlays or lenses: could be chance. Their gain was not confirmed. Against children who got nothing, the gain was "small". Against a placebo, it was "negligible". The authors take this to suggest that the results come mainly from placebo effects.

Other help not confirmed. For sound drills, smooth-reading practice, reading for meaning, listening training and a medicine, the gain was not confirmed. Each had only 2 to 5 comparisons. The medicine's risks "seem to outweigh its benefits", the authors write.

The lesson the authors draw. Working directly on reading and spelling skills "is effective", they write. Help aimed at the causes underneath "could not be confirmed to date".

Hope. Severe reading and spelling trouble "can be ameliorated with appropriate treatment", they write.

7

Why this matters to you, again

  • Fair tests back work on reading itself. That is this review's finding.
  • Colored overlays were not confirmed here. But there were only four comparisons, and the kinds of help did not differ reliably.
  • Few trials for most kinds of help. Phonics was the only one with many.

This page is not medical advice.

The paper's own limits:

  • Blind testing. Most trials did not report it, so most are at risk of bias.
  • Unprinted studies. Weak results likely go unprinted for every kind of help, the authors write.
  • Side findings. Findings on how long, who taught and how severe should be "interpreted with caution".
  • Languages. Studies in several languages were pooled together.
  • Who. Children and teens only, and reports in English only.

A note on names: the paper calls the four colored-filter comparisons "Irlen lenses". We call them colored overlays or lenses.

8

Who did the study, and who paid

Who did it. Four researchers in child and teen psychiatry, at the universities of Munich and Cologne in Germany.

Who paid. A German dyslexia association and a German child psychiatry society. The funders had no role in the study, the paper says.

Conflicts of interest. None, the authors say.

Numbers that disagree. The paper's text says more hours of help seem to work better, but its own table does not show that for hours. So we make no claim about how many hours help should take.