Skip to content

Research Library · Study page

Do colored overlays or lenses help reading? A review of 51 studies

A review of 51 studies found little evidence that colored overlays or lenses help reading. The studies were weak, so that is not proof of no effect.

Study Facts

Griffiths and others, 2016

Review of 51 studies

Question
Do colored overlays or lenses help people read?

What it found

Little evidence that color improves reading. Gains were small, or no bigger than with a placebo.

EvidenceModerate

A careful review, but the studies in it were too weak to pool.

Kids
Poor readers, people with visual stress, and unselected groups
Ages
Children and adults
Size
51 studies, 2,690 people
Fair tests
Most studies had a high or unclear risk of bias
Measured
Reading speed, accuracy and understanding
By
4 researchers: 2 eye doctors, a psychologist, an optometry researcher
Paid by
Not stated
Conflicts
None, the authors say

P. G. Griffiths, R. H. Taylor, L. M. Henderson and Brendan T. Barrett (2016). “The effect of coloured overlays and lenses on reading: a systematic review of the literature.” Ophthalmic & Physiological Optics, 36(5), 519–544. Read the free full text · Publisher's version
Free peer-reviewed manuscript from the University of Bradford. This is the copy we read. The printed version may differ by a word here and there.

Last reviewed November 17, 2026 · Used in: Do colored overlays help with dyslexia?

Go deeper

The study in eight short parts. Tap a part to open it.

1

What is the study?

Four researchers looked at the studies of colored overlays and lenses. Overlays are sheets of colored plastic laid over a page. Lenses are tinted glasses or contact lenses.

The review found 51 studies. They held 54 sets of data and 2,690 people in all. It asked one question: is there good evidence that color helps people read, or learn to read?

2

Why this matters to you

In the UK, overlays are widely handed out, the review notes. Teachers, psychologists and eye clinics give them.

Filters can cost a family a lot of money, the authors write. They may also delay the right help.

3

What was measured?

Reading: how fast, how well, and how much was understood.

The review looked only for studies of reading. Comfort, headaches and eye strain were not its question.

4

Who was measured?

  • Children and adults.
  • Poor readers, people said to have "visual stress", and unselected school groups. There was no limit on how well people read at the start.
  • 2,690 people across the 54 sets of data.

The studies tested four kinds of color system. Fifteen of the data sets tested Irlen's system, the review counts.

5

How was it measured?

  • Only studies with a comparison group were used.
  • Risk of bias. The authors rated each study. Most had a high or unclear risk of bias in at least one key part.
  • No pooled number. The authors write that the field may not be ready for one. So the review describes the studies one by one.
  • Masked trials. In a well-masked trial, people do not know which color is the one being tested. The other color is a placebo.
6

The results

Little evidence that color helps reading. The authors conclude that there is "little evidence" that colored filters improve reading. Many studies did report gains. But the gains were generally small, or about the same as with a placebo.

Not proof of no effect. The authors stress that weak evidence does not prove color has no effect: "lack of evidence is not evidence for a lack of effectiveness".

Masked trials found no gain. In well-masked trials, a chosen color did no better than a placebo color, beyond chance. Studies at lower risk of bias gave less support. The gap between masked and unmasked studies "points strongly to placebo effects", the authors write.

Placebo is the likely reason. Why do people feel a benefit? Placebo, practice and the extra attention of a study are the likely reasons, the authors write.

Same for every system. The results did not differ by which color system was used.

People stop using them. Most studies showed use falling away over time. In one study, 38 of 60 people chose an overlay. Six weeks later, 22 were still using it.

The speed test. Many studies used a speed test made of small, crowded words. It "is not intended to be a test of reading ability" as such, the review notes. Scores also jump on their own. In one study, with no overlay at all, 12.3% of the people tested read more than 15% faster the second time.

Irlen, as the review tells it.

  • In 1983, the review writes, Helen Irlen argued that a problem with seeing was one reason some children struggle to learn to read. She said usual eye exams missed it.
  • In her book, the review writes, she argues that only overlays and lenses from the Irlen Institute work. "However, no scientific evidence supports this claim", the review says.
  • In the studies, Irlen methods gave the label to 46.2% to 96.2% of the people tested, the review counts. That held for normal readers and poor readers alike.
  • The use of Irlen lenses and overlays to improve reading "cannot be endorsed" on the studies so far, the review concludes.
7

Why this matters to you, again

  • Eyes first. The review quotes a UK guideline for optometrists. It says to rule out vision problems with a thorough eye exam before using tinted lenses.
  • Count the cost. Filters can cost a lot, and may delay the right help, the authors write.
  • The question is open. The authors call for large, careful trials. They write that the onus is on those who back filters to gather the evidence.

This page is not medical advice.

The review's own limits:

  • Weak evidence is not proof of no effect.
  • No pooled number. The field may not be ready for one, they write.
  • Reading only. It did not set out to study comfort. In none of the studies did the authors see evidence that color eases symptoms. But a large trial would be needed to answer that, they write.
  • Faults in the best trials. Even the best trials were prone to bias. One of them, of Irlen overlays, may have been too small to find a gain, the authors note.
8

Who did the study, and who paid

Who did it. Four researchers. Two are eye doctors, at hospitals in Gibraltar and York. One is a psychologist at the University of York. One is an optometry researcher at the University of Bradford.

Who paid. Not stated in the copy we read.

Conflicts of interest. None, the authors say.

Numbers that disagree. The paper counts its studies in different ways in different places. We use the count in its summary: 51 studies, 54 sets of data.