Research Library · Study page
Does phonics taught in a planned order help? The National Reading Panel, 2000
A U.S. panel put 38 studies of phonics together. Kids taught phonics in a planned order read better. The gain was medium in size.
Study Facts
National Reading Panel, 2000
Government review of 38 studies
- Question
- Does teaching phonics in a planned order help kids read better?
What it found
A medium gain in reading. It was larger in kindergarten and first grade, but most older kids tested were struggling readers.
EvidenceStrong
38 studies. The fairest tests found the same gain as the rest.
- Kids
- Beginners and struggling readers
- Ages
- Kindergarten to grade 6
- Size
- 38 studies, 66 comparisons
- Fair tests
- 23 of 62 comparisons formed groups at random
- Measured
- Reading words, spelling and understanding text
- By
- The National Reading Panel, 14 members
- Paid by
- A U.S. government panel, set up at the request of Congress
- Conflicts
- Not stated
National Reading Panel (Alphabetics subgroup: Linnea Ehri, chair; Gloria Correro, Timothy Shanahan, Dale Willows, Joanne Yatvin) (2000). “Teaching Children to Read: An Evidence-Based Assessment of the Scientific Research Literature on Reading and Its Implications for Reading Instruction. Reports of the Subgroups. Chapter 2, Part II: Phonics Instruction.” National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, U.S. government report. Read the free full text · Publisher's version
Free U.S. government report. For this page we read only the phonics chapter (it starts at page 2-89), the members page and the panel's charge.
Last reviewed November 17, 2026 · Used in: Phonics or whole language: which works better?
Go deeper
The study in eight short parts. Tap a part to open it.
1What is the study?
In 1997, Congress asked for a panel to look at the research on how to teach reading. The National Reading Panel had 14 members. Its report came out in 2000. This page is about one part of it: phonics.
Phonics teaches which letters stand for which sounds, and how to blend the sounds into words. In systematic phonics, the letter sounds are taught in a planned order.
The panel found 38 studies of phonics. From them it drew 66 comparisons. Each set kids taught phonics in a planned order against kids taught phonics with no set order, or none.
2Why this matters to you
Every school teaches reading in some way. The panel asked a plain question. Does phonics in a planned order help kids read better than other ways?
One other way was whole language. In it, reading and writing for meaning come first. Phonics is taught too, but only when the teacher decides it is needed. By the 1980s and 1990s, a first grade program with no phonics was rare, the panel says.
3What was measured?
Six kinds of reading skill:
- Reading real words that follow the rules.
- Reading made-up words.
- Reading other words, some of which break the rules.
- Spelling.
- Understanding text read silently or aloud.
- Reading text aloud correctly.
About three in four results were for single words. Only about one in four were for reading text.
4Who was measured?
Kids from kindergarten to grade 6.
- Kids with reading problems were in about two in three comparisons. Some were at risk or low achievers. Others had been found to have a reading disability.
- Typical readers above first grade were in only seven comparisons. Four of these came from one study.
Most of the studies were done in the United States.
5How was it measured?
- Only studies printed in journals that review their papers, from after 1970.
- Two groups in each study. One was taught phonics in a planned order. The other was taught phonics with no set order, or none.
- Fair tests. In 23 of 62 comparisons, kids were put into groups at random. That is the fairest kind of test. The gain in these was about the same as in the rest.
6The results
Phonics in a planned order came out ahead. Kids taught this way read better than kids taught with no set order or no phonics. The gain was medium in size.
It beat each kind of other teaching. That included whole language and whole word teaching. The gain over whole language classes was the smallest, and it rests on 12 comparisons. But the panel found that these gains did not differ from each other.
The gain was larger early. It was larger in kindergarten and first grade than in grades 2 to 6. But most of the older children were struggling readers, the panel warns. So age may not be the reason.
Older low achievers: no clear gain. In grades 2 to 6, their gain was small and could be chance. It came from only eight comparisons in three studies. The panel drew no conclusion for them. Kids with a reading disability did gain.
Word reading gained most. Understanding text gained too, but less. For young kids, the gain in understanding was clear. For older kids as a group, it could be chance.
Spelling. Kindergartners and first graders spelled much better. Older kids did not: their gain could be chance.
It lasted, but shrank. A few studies tested kids again 4 months to 1 year later. The gain was still there, but smaller.
Kinds of phonics did not differ. Some programs teach kids to say each sound and blend. Others work with larger parts of words. The gains did not differ reliably. Tutoring, small groups and whole classes all worked too.
Phonics did not hurt understanding. The panel says its findings should end any belief that teaching phonics to young children gets in the way of understanding text. "Quite the opposite is the case", it writes.
7Why this matters to you, again
- Ask for a planned order. Phonics taught this way came out ahead.
- Start early. The largest gains were in kindergarten and first grade.
- Phonics is one part. "Phonics instruction is never a total reading program", the panel writes. It calls phonics "a means to an end". It should not take over a reading program, in time or in weight.
The panel's own limits:
- Some phonics, not none. Some comparison classes got no phonics. Others got some. So a "substantial number" of studies may have compared more phonics with less, the panel notes.
- Comparing studies. Its findings on ages and on kinds of phonics come from comparing one study with another. That is weaker than a direct test.
- Mostly single words, not text.
- Journals only. Studies with no gain are less often printed, the panel notes. That can tilt results toward good news.
- Typical older readers. There was too little data to draw any conclusion for them.
8Who did the study, and who paid
Who did it. The National Reading Panel, 14 members. Five of them formed the subgroup on alphabetics, which covered phonics.
Who paid. A U.S. government panel, set up at the request of Congress.
Conflicts of interest. Not stated.
Numbers that disagree. The report gives different numbers in different places for kindergarten, and for how well kids with a reading disability understood text. So we print none of them.
