Skip to content

Research Library · Study page

What does the science of reading show? A 2020 review by 12 researchers

Twelve reading researchers list what has strong evidence and what lacks it. Planned phonics is strongly backed. Three-cueing lacks support.

Study Facts

Petscher and others, 2020

Expert review

Question
What does reading research show clearly?

What it found

Strong support for planned, explicit phonics. Three-cueing lacks support and goes "directly against" what is known.

EvidenceExpert view

Twelve researchers' summary. All work at one research center.

What it is
A summary of other research
Looked at
Which teaching practices have strong studies behind them
By
12 researchers, Florida Center for Reading Research
Paid by
The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative and two U.S. government research agencies
Conflicts
Not stated

Yaacov Petscher, Sonia Q. Cabell, Hugh W. Catts, Donald L. Compton, Barbara R. Foorman, Sara A. Hart, Christopher J. Lonigan, Beth M. Phillips, Christopher Schatschneider, Laura M. Steacy, Nicole Patton Terry and Richard K. Wagner (2020). “How the Science of Reading Informs 21st-Century Education.” Reading Research Quarterly, 55(S1), S267–S282. Read the free full text · Publisher's version
Free author copy on PubMed Central. This is the copy we read.

Last reviewed November 17, 2026 · Used in: Phonics or whole language: which works better?

Go deeper

The study in eight short parts. Tap a part to open it.

1

What is the study?

A review by 12 reading researchers. All of them work at the Florida Center for Reading Research, at Florida State University. They sum up what the science of reading has learned.

They sort ways of teaching into three groups. Some have "compelling evidence", in their view. Some have "promising evidence". Some have "a lack of compelling evidence".

It is not a search of every study. It sets out what the authors "believe" has strong evidence.

2

Why this matters to you

Schools hear a lot about "the science of reading". This paper says what that phrase covers, from people who study it. It also names common practices that lack strong support, decodable books among them.

3

What was measured?

No children were tested. The authors looked at which teaching practices have strong studies behind them, from early sound skills to reading for meaning.

4

Who was measured?

No one, directly. The paper measured no children of its own. It sums up other research.

5

How was it measured?

  • A summary of other studies, chosen by the authors.
  • No pooled numbers of its own.
  • Not a full list. They "lack sufficient space" to list every practice without strong evidence, they write.
6

The results

Strongly backed: decoding taught clearly and in a planned order. "A large evidence base provides strong support" for teaching decoding and the skills it is built on this way, they write.

  • Teaching sound skills and letter knowledge, especially together, improves decoding.
  • This holds for kids who speak only English and for kids with another home language. It also holds for kids who struggle to read.

Decoding is half of it. Readers need skills in both decoding words and understanding language. A weakness in either one holds back reading, they write.

Three-cueing lacks support. In three-cueing, a child stuck on a word uses meaning, grammar and letter clues together to guess it. The authors list it among practices that "lack generalizable empirical support". They also say it goes "directly against" what is known.

  • Why. Kids store words in memory by linking letters to sounds. "Guessing at a word amounts to a lost learning trial", they write: a lost chance to learn the word.
  • Speed. Leaning on other clues gets in the way of fast word reading, they write.
  • What the paper does not show. It reports no trial of three-cueing itself. Its case is that no good studies back it, and that it runs against how researchers say children learn words.

The other side, as they report it. Ken Goodman, who backed three-cueing, said in an interview that it rests on years of watching readers. It is a different kind of evidence from lab science, in his view. "My science is different", he said.

Other practices on the same list. Close reading, decodable books, silent reading time and multisensory teaching also lack strong support, the authors write.

  • Decodable books. Only one study tested more against fewer decodable books, for first graders at risk. It found no differences. The authors add that this "does not rule out" that the books are useful.
  • Multisensory teaching. There is "little scientific evidence" that it beats similar sound-based teaching without a strong multisensory part.

Named programs, as they tell it. They name what they call the five most popular reading programs in U.S. schools. They are Units of Study for Teaching Reading, Journeys, Into Reading, Leveled Literacy Intervention and Reading Recovery.

  • Only two had studies that met U.S. government standards: Leveled Literacy Intervention and Reading Recovery. Both are for struggling readers.
  • For Leveled Literacy Intervention, the results were mixed.
  • For Reading Recovery, they were positive or potentially positive.

We have not read those studies. The paper does not say how these programs teach children to read words.

Why the debate goes on, in their view. Most of it is about what counts as evidence from science. It is also about how much weight that evidence should get, and how new teachers should learn to teach reading.

7

Why this matters to you, again

  • Ask whether decoding is taught clearly and in a planned order.
  • When your child is stuck on a word, point to the letters. A guess is a lost chance to learn the word, the authors write.
  • Ask what is behind a practice. Even common practices, such as decodable books and multisensory teaching, lack strong studies in this paper's view.

The paper's own limits:

  • It sets out what the authors "believe" has strong evidence. It is not a systematic review.
  • It is not a full list of practices without strong evidence.
  • It gives no trial of three-cueing itself.
  • It says nothing about laws, or about schools dropping three-cueing.
8

Who did the study, and who paid

Who did it. Twelve researchers, all at the Florida Center for Reading Research, Florida State University. All twelve are named at the top of this page.

Who paid. The Chan Zuckerberg Initiative paid for the work. So did two U.S. government research agencies. One is the Institute of Education Sciences. The other is a health research institute for children.

Conflicts of interest. Not stated in the copy we read.