Skip to content

Research Library · Study page

Do reading gains last? A 2016 review of 71 comparisons

Did the gains from reading help last? This review looked at kids tested again, about 11 months later. Gains from sound-only teaching mostly held.

Study Facts

Suggate, 2016

Review of 71 comparisons

Question
Do the gains from reading help last?

What it found

Gains from sound-only teaching mostly held. Across all kinds of reading help, gains shrank.

EvidenceModerate

One author, and he says the numbers are likely a little too high.

Kids
All levels, from typical to reading-disabled
Ages
Preschool to grade 6
Size
71 comparisons, 8,161 kids
Fair tests
About half put kids into groups at random
Measured
Reading skills, about 11 months after the teaching ended
By
1 researcher, University of Regensburg, Germany
Paid by
No funding for the study, the paper says
Conflicts
None, the author says

Sebastian P. Suggate (2016). “A Meta-Analysis of the Long-Term Effects of Phonemic Awareness, Phonics, Fluency, and Reading Comprehension Interventions.” Journal of Learning Disabilities, 49(1), 77–96. Read the free full text · Publisher's version
Free copy on the University of Regensburg's publication server. This is the copy we read.

Last reviewed November 17, 2026 · Used in: Does phonemic awareness training help?

Go deeper

The study in eight short parts. Tap a part to open it.

1

What is the study?

A review by one researcher, Sebastian Suggate. Many studies test kids right after the teaching ends. Few test them again later. This review gathered the ones that did.

It found 71 comparisons. Each set a group that got reading help against a comparison group. In 17 of them, the help was phonemic awareness on its own. The rest tested phonics, smooth reading, reading for meaning, or a mix.

What "phonemic awareness" means here. He counted a program as phonemic awareness only if it worked with sounds and no letters. Any program with letters went into his "phonics" group, even if it also taught sounds. So in this review, teaching sounds with letters sits in the phonics group.

2

Why this matters to you

Reading help takes time. You want the gain to last after the help ends. This review asked whether it does, and what kind of help lasts best.

3

What was measured?

Reading skills, tested right after the teaching and again later. The later test came about 11 months after, on average.

There were four kinds of test:

  • Early skills, such as sounds, letters and sounding out.
  • Reading words and text.
  • Reading for meaning.
  • Spelling.
4

Who was measured?

  • 8,161 kids at the first test.
  • From preschool to about grade 6. The average was around grade 1.
  • All levels. Some were typical readers. Some were at risk. Some were low readers. Some had a reading disability.

The sound-only lessons went to young kids. On average they were between kindergarten and grade 1.

5

How was it measured?

Each study compared a group that got reading help with a comparison group. Both were tested right after, then again later.

  • About half of the studies put kids into groups at random. In the others, the groups had to start out at about the same level.
  • Only studies printed in journals that review their papers were used.
  • Some studies seemed to be missing. The author found signs that small studies with poor results were not printed. So he says the numbers are likely a little too high.
  • Bigger studies counted more. He gave each study weight by its size. A 2021 paper by other researchers says this choice "has been debated".
6

The results

Overall, gains shrank. Across all kinds of reading help, the gain was smaller at the later test than right after.

Sound-only teaching mostly held. Most of its gain was still there at the later test.

Phonics gains faded in this review. The author calls the poor showing of phonics next to sound-only teaching "a surprising finding". But two very large phonics studies had small later gains. They pulled the phonics average down. The author very tentatively suggests that large sound-only studies would show the same drop.

Struggling readers kept more. Kids at risk, low readers and reading-disabled readers kept more of their gain than typical readers.

The youngest kept little. For all kinds of help given in preschool and kindergarten, only a small gain was left later. The author calls it "marginal".

One-to-one was not clearly better than small groups.

Help on top of usual lessons did better than help given in place of them.

His suggestion. Teach sound-only skills in preschool and kindergarten, and decoding in grades 1 and 2. This is his suggestion, not a tested result. Other researchers find that reading results are stronger when sounds are taught with letters.

7

Why this matters to you, again

  • Gains can fade. On average, a smaller gain was left about 11 months later.
  • Sound-only teaching held up here, but on 17 comparisons. And this review did not test sounds alone against sounds with letters head to head.
  • Help for struggling readers is not wasted. They kept more of their gain than typical readers.

The author lists his own limits:

  • Studies with poor results seem to be missing, so the numbers are likely a little too high.
  • Many studies did not say what kids got after the help ended.
  • There were too few studies to tell apart the role of age and the kind of help.
  • More large studies are needed, he writes.
8

Who did the study, and who paid

Who did it. One researcher, Sebastian P. Suggate, at the University of Regensburg in Germany.

Who paid. No funding for the study, the paper says. He did part of the work while he held a fellowship from the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation.

Conflicts of interest. None, the author says.

Numbers that disagree. The paper gives different numbers in different places for sound-only teaching against phonics. So we print none of them.