Skip to content

Research Library · Study page

Do colored filters help reading? A 2018 review of four reviews

Three researchers compared four reviews of colored overlays and lenses. Three found too little good evidence. So far the evidence is not reliable, they say.

Study Facts

Suttle and others, 2018

Review of 4 earlier reviews

Question
Do colored filters ease reading problems?

What it found

Three of four reviews found too little good evidence. Overall: no reliable evidence yet.

EvidenceModerate

A set plan and a standard checklist. But only four reviews, each with gaps.

Kids
People with reading trouble or discomfort
Ages
Children and adults
Size
4 reviews, from 2008 to 2016
Fair tests
Its plan was set down before the work began
Measured
What each review found, and how sound it was
By
3 researchers, City, University of London
Paid by
Not stated
Conflicts
Not stated

C. M. Suttle, J. G. Lawrenson and M. L. Conway (2018). “Efficacy of coloured overlays and lenses for treating reading difficulty: an overview of systematic reviews.” Clinical and Experimental Optometry, 101(4), 514–520. Read the free full text · Publisher's version
Free accepted manuscript from City, University of London. This is the copy we read. The printed version may differ.

Last reviewed November 17, 2026 · Used in: Do colored overlays help with dyslexia?

Go deeper

The study in eight short parts. Tap a part to open it.

1

What is the study?

A paper by three researchers in London. A full review gathers all the studies on a question. This paper gathered the reviews themselves, so it is a review of reviews.

It found four, from 2008 to 2016, and compared what each one did and found. Its question: do colored filters ease reading problems?

2

Why this matters to you

Parents of children with reading trouble may find claims of a treatment that works "appealing", the authors write.

Different reviews have reached different answers. This paper puts them side by side.

3

What was measured?

For each review: what it did, what it found, what it concluded, and how sound its method was. The authors judged each review on a standard checklist.

4

Who was measured?

No one, directly. The paper measured no people. It read four reviews:

  • one from 2008 (Albon and others),
  • one from 2014, on help for reading disabilities (Galuschka and others),
  • two from 2016 (Griffiths and others; Evans and Allen).

All four looked at children who had trouble or discomfort when reading. Three also looked at adults.

5

How was it measured?

  • A plan set down first. The authors registered their plan before the work began. None of the four reviews had done that, they found.
  • A standard checklist for judging how sound each review was.
  • Words, not numbers. The four reviews differed too much to pool. So the authors compared them in words.
6

The results

Three of four found too little good evidence. Three reviews found too little good evidence to back colored overlays or lenses for reading trouble.

One found that the evidence does back them. In people with visual stress, "the balance of evidence suggests" filters can ease symptoms or help performance, the 2016 review by Evans and Allen concluded.

  • The overview's authors call that conclusion "surprising", given the limits its own authors admit.
  • They add that it did name the costs: time, money and raised hopes.

Overall: no reliable evidence yet. There is "not yet a reliable evidence base" to recommend colored overlays or lenses, the authors conclude. So filters should not be recommended for reading trouble until there is reliable evidence, they write.

It might work. "It is possible that they are effective, but a lack of reliable research to date means that this is not yet known."

Placebo. When reading is tested with and without color, a placebo effect is very likely, the authors write. A gain may come from a wish or a hope, not from any real effect on how we see.

Harm and cost. Filters are "unlikely to cause harm" to health, they write, agreeing with Evans and Allen. But they cost money. They raise hopes that may end in disappointment. And other help may be neglected.

Why it is debated. Research groups do not agree on which colors help, the authors note. Some say blue or yellow. Others say any color.

The names. Visual stress and Meares-Irlen syndrome are names for the same reading trouble or discomfort, the authors write.

7

Why this matters to you, again

  • No reliable evidence yet. That is not the same as proof that filters never help.
  • Weigh the costs. The authors point to money, raised hopes and other help that may be neglected.
  • Better research is needed, in children and adults. The authors call for "carefully conducted, unbiased research".

This page is not medical advice.

The paper's own limits:

  • Only four reviews. They had different people, ages and methods, so the authors compared them in words only.
  • Gaps in all four. Each review had weak spots in method. Two pooled weak studies anyway.
  • A changed checklist. The authors switched to a newer version of their checklist partway through, and say so.

A note of ours, not the authors': the four reviews overlap in the trials they read. So three of the four is not three separate proofs.

8

Who did the study, and who paid

Who did it. Three researchers at City, University of London.

Who paid. Not stated in the copy we read.

Conflicts of interest. Not stated in the copy we read.