Research Library · Study page
Do colored filters help visual stress? A 2016 review in favor
Two researchers looked at trials of one colored filter for visual stress. They find the evidence leans toward filters, with some cautions.
Study Facts
Evans and Allen, 2016
Review of trials of one filter system
- Question
- Do colored filters help people with visual stress?
What it found
All 10 overlay trials found a gain. The "balance of evidence" favors filters, the authors say.
EvidenceLimited
One filter system, and overlay trials that could not be masked.
- Kids
- People picked as having visual stress
- Ages
- 5 years and older
- Size
- 10 overlay trials and 3 lens trials
- Fair tests
- Overlay trials cannot be masked, the authors say
- Measured
- Reading speed on a special test, and symptoms
- By
- 2 researchers, London and Cambridge, UK
- Paid by
- No outside funding, the paper says
- Conflicts
- Disclosed: one author is paid for lectures and is unpaid secretary of a colored lens society
Bruce J. W. Evans and Peter M. Allen (2016). “A systematic review of controlled trials on visual stress using Intuitive Overlays or the Intuitive Colorimeter.” Journal of Optometry, 9(4), 205–218. Read the free full text · Publisher's version
Free copy on PubMed Central. This is the copy we read.
Last reviewed November 17, 2026 · Used in: Do colored overlays help with dyslexia?
Go deeper
The study in eight short parts. Tap a part to open it.
1What is the study?
A review by two researchers, Bruce Evans and Peter Allen. It is the one review we read that comes out in favor of colored filters. It looked at trials of one filter system. The people in them were picked as having "visual stress".
Visual stress is a name for a set of complaints, the authors write. Print looks distorted. Headaches and eye strain come on when looking at patterns, such as lines of text.
2Why this matters to you
If you have heard that colored filters help, this review sets out the case for them. Here it is in its own terms first, with its own cautions after.
3What was measured?
Mostly reading speed on a special test made of small, crowded words, built to bring on the symptoms. Also the symptoms people reported.
4Who was measured?
- People picked as having visual stress, aged 5 and up.
- Not people picked for dyslexia. Studies that chose people only for dyslexia, or by Irlen's rules, were left out of this review.
- One filter system: colored sheets and a lens-testing tool built by one researcher. The authors chose it because it is fully written up in science journals, they write.
5How was it measured?
- Controlled trials only. Each compared the chosen color with a control, such as grey.
- 10 overlay trials and 3 lens trials.
- No masking for overlays. "It is not possible to mask participants in a trial comparing coloured overlays with a control", the authors write. That is a risk of bias, they add.
- No pooled number.
6The results
All 10 overlay trials found a gain with each person's chosen overlay. All three lens trials found a gain too.
The balance of evidence. In people with visual stress, "the balance of evidence suggests" that colored filters can ease symptoms or help performance, the authors conclude.
Not a treatment for dyslexia. Filters "are not a treatment for dyslexia", the authors write.
- Visual stress is distinct from dyslexia, though the two sometimes occur together, they write.
- Most people with dyslexia do not have visual stress, they write.
- By the authors' estimate, about 20% of children with dyslexia have it.
Big claims lack evidence. Some say that more than 10% of all people would gain from filters, and 50% of people with dyslexia. Those claims "lack sound evidence", the authors write.
On Irlen, as this review tells it. Irlen's approach is not fully written up in science journals, this review notes, and has been criticised for that. It finds visual stress in close to 80% of people with reading problems, so it over-diagnoses, this review adds.
Their own cautions:
- The field lacks the large trials that new drugs would need.
- The evidence is weaker than new medical treatments would need.
- A colored page looks different, and a child may take that as relief. Through a placebo effect, that may lead to better scores, the authors write. They cannot completely rule out placebo effects.
- Many children stop. In one set of studies, ten months on, 21% of the children who had asked for an overlay were still using it.
- Larger, rigorous randomized trials are needed.
7Why this matters to you, again
- An eye exam first. For children who struggle at school, an eye exam is "a sensible precaution", the authors write. Any vision problem should be treated in the usual way before trying filters.
- Count the cost. Any treatment costs a family money, time and raised hopes, they note.
- Do not overstate the case. Where evidence is weak, those who give out filters "should be particularly careful not to overstate the case", the authors write.
- Other reviews disagree. A 2018 overview questioned this review's conclusion.
This page is not medical advice.
The paper's own limits:
- No large randomized trials exist yet.
- Overlay trials cannot be masked.
- Diagnosis. How visual stress is diagnosed needs more research, they write.
- One system. It covers one filter system only.
- One kind of test. Most of the gains were measured on the special speed test of small, crowded words.
8Who did the study, and who paid
Who did it. Two researchers. Bruce J. W. Evans works at the Institute of Optometry in London. Peter M. Allen works at Anglia Ruskin University in Cambridge, UK.
Who paid. No outside funding, the paper says.
Conflicts of interest. Disclosed. The authors have no financial interest in any colored filter system, they write. Professor Evans has been paid for talks and has been an expert witness on this topic. He is the unpaid secretary of a not-for-profit society of colored lens prescribers.
